by Berimbau » Wed Jan 04, 2006 5:36 pm
Happy New Year Everyone,
I really enjoyed seeing Pavloconga's interesting pictures of the Ghanian drum battery. The technology represented by the peg-tuning system is a VERY GOOD diagnostic marker for a specific area of coastal West Africa where it's use is so dilineated. Although these peg-tuned drums were present in Cuba, the Ghanian drums and their associated repertoire have little, if anything, to do with the development of Afro-Cuban rumba, but let me return to that issue a bit later.
However, there is some evidence of the wide-spread diffusion of this peg-tuning technology in many New World cultures. There is a drum in the British Museum collected in 18th century Virgina by Sir Henry Sloane that is nearly identical to a contemporary Ghanaian apenti drum. Whether it was actually manufactured in Virginia by an African-American slave or taken aboard a slave ship to "dance" (exercise) the captives has been debated without a clear answer. Perhaps a wood/hide expert could put us onto a clearer path here. As my own field photos are gone with Katrina, a good picture of the drum appears in Dena Epstein's much recommended book, "Sinful Tunes & Spirituals." The late Harold Courlander once kindly sent me his field drawing of the remanents of a slave-made peg drum being used by an African-American family as a grain barrel in 1950's Alabama. Other references to African-derived peg drums come from the Georgia Sea Islands where at least one maker survived into the 1930's, read the book "Drums & Shadows," culled from a fine ethnographic survey conducted by the W.P.A. back in the day. The ethnomusicologist David Evans discovered that the Grandfather of one of his infiormants, Eli Owens, also made peg-style drums in turn of the century South Mississippi. Further evidence comes from the Houma Indians who seem to have borrowed the technology to create a transcultural membranophone circa 1905.
Now back to our contemporary Ghanian photos where one should note that the Malian style djembe, formerly quite foreign in Ghanian traditional ensembles, now finds a place of pride there. With the ascendancy of the djembe in Western culture, makers ALL over Africa are "recreating" this venerable tradition to feed the burgeoning market for African music. Now even Balinese makers are also helping to fill that need. Culture is learnable and forever changing, as these pictures so clearly indicate.
So what what then is the ultimate African source of rumba? I believe that this is a loaded question as rumba is CLEARLY a Cuban artform, informed by both African and European musical values. However, as so many of my colleagues have so asstutely pointed out, it was the tambors Yuka, the tambors Ngoma, and other Central African-derived traditions that are at the heart of rumba organology. Surely Yoruba, Spanish, and other cultural influences are evident in the syncretic rumba, but there is little evidence of any direct Ghanian influences.
Back to our peg-tuned drums. In Cuba they seem to come from two sources, Fon-speaking slaves extracted from Benin, and a secondary prolifferation from Haitian migrant agricultural workers. It IS possible that the loop and peg tuning system, present in Cuban communities, may have influenced the later development of the tuning hardware used on the tumbadoras, but the jury is still out. I DO think this is quite tenable as NO other European or African technology seems to provides us with a better "fit," if I may so pun. Of course all should consult the works Fernando Ortiz, Olavo Rodriguez, Ned Sublette, and Nolan Warden for a more comprehensive overview of rumba histiography.
Saludos,
Berimbau
.