FidelsEyeglasses wrote:For me personally, an instrument that is constructed of/with organic wood/s as in an acoustic bass, violin, cello, snare drum shell etc. are different then metal mouthpieces for horns, where as in wood/en instruments the type/s of glue, gluing techniques, clamping and steaming that are for me as well as by the maker (whoever it is) major factors that contribute to the pricing of those instruments.
Wynton Marsalis does not choose the lowest priced trumpet mouth piece he can find or is offered.
Ron Carter does not choose the lowest priced acoustic bass he can find or is offered.
Akua Dixon does not choose the lowest priced cello she can find or is offered.
The above instruments involve gluing, steaming, cutting, bending and....organic wood. [/i]
El Magnifico wrote:FidelsEyeglasses wrote:
Ron Carter does not choose the lowest priced acoustic bass he can find or is offered.
Akua Dixon does not choose the lowest priced cello she can find or is offered.
The above instruments involve gluing, steaming, cutting, bending and....organic wood.
I am fortunate to be able to base my point of reference on Vergara, Requena, Skin on Skin, Junior Tirado, Matt Smiths Ritmo, JCR, all of which I have actually seen in front of me, played or owned, the last three are generally easily found and seen in the area where I live, but in other countries and even on the west coast of the U.S. those brands are scarce and not 'commonly' found, so when many peoples points of reference are based on what's available to them whether being Tycoon/Mountain rhythm/CP/Toca/LP Aspire/Toca/Meinl/lower end Gon Bops/Pearl/Meinl "Free Ride"/Schalloch Linea/LP Durian Bongos/LP Galaxy or any "series".
Anything is better than nothing... but If the base of reference is limited to low to mid range drums both in price and materiels, then when someone see's a photo of a Matt Smith Spanish Ceder, or black Walnut drum priced accordingly, it's common and not surprising for some to think in terms of "stratospheric" or "simply and purely a status symbol purchase"."And you know about those musicians for sure? Or are you just guessing?"
For sure, no guessing.... I've known Wynton since he was I teenager, I lived in in New Orleans from 1974-1986 and continue to know him as we both live in N.Y.C. and I know who makes his mouth pieces and sells them and they don't come from Sears.
Ron Carter, for sure, no guessing... I've known him for 25 years as well as played with him, I know where his bass's come from who made them and they are not from Musicians Friend or Guitar Center.
If you personally feel it's [inot practical sense to pay that amount of money for a bongo"
As far as you reading music, definitely an asset to any musician, keep in mind Mongo, Patato and Aguabella didn't read.you are assuming too much and segmented phrases of whole lines of thinking
I like segmented phrases in 6/8.
Unfortunately, Fidel, it looks lie you are assuming too much and choosing segmented phrases of whole lines of thinking which takes it completely out of context. Incidentally, I don't have any of those "El Cheapo" brands you mentioned as references, but I understand your point. You can check my collection somewhere else in this forum. My referencece point is very high indeed as well as my experience playing and studying percussion. I read music and I can play a bongo partiture at first sight, but that's not the point here.
To begin with, those terms we have used to describe the price perception are highly SUBJECTIVE. That means that all of us are, in a certain manner, CORRECT. The respect any instrument deserve has nothing to do with the price, maker, brand or anything else. It's an intimate relationship between the instrument and the player, a thing, again, highly subjective and personal that nobody should argue about.
In my case, I don't see the need, nor the practical sense to pay that amount of money for a bongo. BUT that's me and I don't personally fit in any of the assumptions you made concerning "limited references", "pricing accordingly" etc... It's a matter of beign human. Again, if you feel buying a "costly" bongo makes you happy and you find the right motives to do so, well, by all means do it! If the rest of us choose to play a Timba or El Cheapo brand, that doesn't make us lesser musicians, or that we don't have the funds to buy one MS or mean that we are wrong.
So, at the end, nobody is wrong or right because it's a matter of perception and because of that, I don't see the need to continue this discussion. Thanks for a very healthy thread.
RUMBA!
blavonski wrote:FidelsEyeglasses wrote:For me personally, an instrument that is constructed of/with organic wood/s as in an acoustic bass, violin, cello, snare drum shell etc. are different then metal mouthpieces for horns, where as in wood/en instruments the type/s of glue, gluing techniques, clamping and steaming that are for me as well as by the maker (whoever it is) major factors that contribute to the pricing of those instruments.
Wynton Marsalis does not choose the lowest priced trumpet mouth piece he can find or is offered.
Ron Carter does not choose the lowest priced acoustic bass he can find or is offered.
Akua Dixon does not choose the lowest priced cello she can find or is offered.
The above instruments involve gluing, steaming, cutting, bending and....organic wood. [/i]
I understand and appreciate your personal point of view and references here Markito;
however, I do find your perspective to be based on extremes. You choose to make comparisons between what you refer to as Mass produced drums to custom produced drums. When in fact Caballballo raised the question of being able to purchase three moderately priced custom made Bongos for the price of one very highly or extravagantly priced Custom Bongó. I understand that you consider yourself an officianado if not an athority of sorts in regards to Cuban Music, culture and it's drums and your website definately reveals your itimate relationship to that Culture and music. And although I respect and appreciate your perspective, I think that relationship creates a little proprietary bias on your part concerning M. Smiths productions of his interpretations of traditonal Cuban drums.
Among other things, I'm a wood worker and metal worker and if I had the machinery to cut, smooth and shape wood and metal to produce Bongos and Congas, I could be able to sell them for half of what he does and reap amodest and acceptable profit margin. Now you would probably respond that the quality may not be the same and I would say, yes it would; because if I can build a pair of Bongos with pure human energy hand driven tools at the level that I recently have, then certainly using machines, which I have experience with, would be a breeze and ten times faster of course. And as far as wood prices go, we're not talking a lot of wood for the exotic bongo shells here. Hand work craftmanship is one thing when your cutting, smoothing and shaping and assembling with hand, human energy tools than being able set up machines that do the work of hands. If M. Smith were producing his drums in the human energy driven manner, then I could understand his prices. But, who does or can do that anymore in our society and earn a modest living from it? I will be starting on a pair of Bongo shells for some one soon, out of the wood of their choice. And, I will be using the Techniques as I did before and am doing it for price that covers my time at a cost I can live with, because I enjoy the process. And someone will have a pair of Bongos, (shells), made of a wood that they have chosen with details and bearing edges that suites their playing style for less than mid to top line Meinl Or LP Bongos made in Thailand cost.
M. Smith is obviously also doing what he loves to do, make drums and money, and he has filled a niche with his drums that satisfy the mostly aesthetic desires of those who are willing to pay him for it. That's the bases of our Market driven economy. Ritmo drums is a brand name, albeit a comparatively small one, and like all other brand names, it has it's faithful followers that help to maintain it's esteemed place at the top of their list of what they deem to be the best. Also, due to this reputation his restoration and or repair services are also extravagantly priced. People send him drums from europe even to have reapeired because he's Mat Smith, not because a reputable and experienced carpenters or furniture builders and refinishers in there land couldn't do the work. That's the lure of a brand name.
As far as Saxophone mouth pieces: My reference was to Ligatures. However, mouthpieces for saxes and clarinets are made of Wood, Hard rubber and Metal all organic, elemental materials that all require the processes you mention above and then there's plastic. And the same merry go round of which is the best made by this crafts person or vintage company is also a characteristic with these products. Again you use extremes like lowest price vs most expensive. There is a middle ground, and whether one is forced by economics to choose it or not, is more likely than not the way to go. But, being able to make that decision requires information about a product; how it's made what It's made of etc. Most people are lured by cheap prices for quick fix or high price flash and status aquisition. When I use the term Status, I'm refering the position that the aquisition of any thing places one in relation to those that can't aquire a particular thing as well as to those that have what they have or want to have. Any one who collects things for there monetary or percieved market value is engaging in status thinking. I'm not judging it, just seeing it for what it is.
Good vibrations,
Blavonski
[b]FidelsEyeglasses wrote:
Just to be clear as to what I consider "mass" produced:
Mass produced = a company easily produces/makes 15 - 25 or more bongoes/congas per month and has no "waiting list".
As opposed to drum makers Jay Bereck or Matt Smith that produce "far less" then that in a months time and do have a "waiting list".
There is not an extreme perspective between those two. I disagree with you here still.
Some people seem to be confused with "custom made" vs "hand made" specifically when related to pricing.
there's no confusion for me here. Something custom made can be either hand made or programmed into a machine and spat out in ten minutes. I think there's much confusion however regarding what's known as "Hand made" vs " Really Hand made" or as David Pye refers to it in his book "The Nature and Art of Workmanship", as[i] The workmanship of risk, vs that of certainty"[/i]
Mr. Blavonski, whether you do or don't consider me any kind of "authority of sorts in regards to Cuban Music, culture and it's drums" or any kind of web site has absolutely nothing to do with those of us that think that a pair of bongoes made with Spanish Ceder, black Walnut, African Mahogany and that start at a particular price point is completely acceptable and is not a "a status symbol purchase".[i] Well, I think it does considering that what you have praised about the work of Jay B and Mat Smith, is their mainting a Traditional Cuban aesthetik in regard to form in the building of thier drums.
But for some folks to make "written in stone" statements: [i]"stratospheric", "insane price", "overpriced", "a status symbol purchase"[i] etc. shows a lack of something, I don't what to call it other than going into shock from perhaps never having experienced owning a custom made conga or pair bongoes that cost more that $200.00-$300.00-$400.00? I don't think these adjectives show a lack of any kind on those including myself who have used them, it simply expresses their opinion, that greatly contrasts with yours.
Mr. Blavonski could you kindly share with me what for you personally would consider to be a price for a pair of bongoes that at 1.00 more would be [i]overpriced and at 1.00 over would be "a status symbol purchase"?
To me a musical instrument is "too expensive" if someone simply can't afford the price, or alternatively the quality/fit/finish/materials and sound is absolutely not equitable to what you get for the price asked.Or, I would add, said quality/fit/finish can be had for less
"A drum is a drum, is a drum" is not true in my experience, a finely made custom drum is like a fine violin, cello, viola or bass with the skin choice being like the strings that make the drum sing.I couldn't agree with you more here.
Some people prefer an affordable bike, others prefer a higher end bike in both materiel's and workmanship, though both get you to the same destination.Yes, so why buy the BMW when The VW will get you there and back in one peice for the same length of time? Well, for luxury and because one can afford it and it puts them in the same line as the other BMW owners. We're conditioned to want more than we need and likewise conditioned to work our asses off, slaving, voluntarily that is, in order to aquire it, and some just got it like that. Enjoy your drums.
blavonski wrote:FidelsEyeglasses wrote:
Just to be clear as to what I consider "mass" produced:
Mass produced = a company easily produces/makes 15 - 25 or more bongoes/congas per month and has no "waiting list".
As opposed to drum makers Jay Bereck or Matt Smith that produce "far less" then that in a months time and do have a "waiting list".
There is not an extreme perspective between those two.
I disagree with you here still.
I welcome healthy debate and I respect your opinion/s though I may not agree with some of them.
Some people seem to be confused with "custom made" vs "hand made" specifically when related to pricing.
There's no confusion for me here. Something custom made can be either hand made or programmed into a machine and spat out in ten minutes.
Just because someone pressed (touched) some buttons and programed a machine does not to me equate to "made by hand" if the machine did 99.9 % of the work then spat it out in 10 min.
I think there's much confusion however regarding what's known as "Hand made" vs " Really Hand made" or as David Pye refers to it in his book "The Nature and Art of Workmanship", as The workmanship of risk, vs that of certainty
Again, I refer to "custom made" vs "hand made"... not "Hand made" vs " Really Hand made".
So obviously we can debate the semantics of "custom made" vs "hand made" forever.
If I walk down a street somewhere in the Caribbean and a Woman (or Man) is selling maracas and/or Güiros on a table or sitting in the street selling them out of a bag or basket, and they made them, or a family member made them... for me, they are "hand made" not "custom" made.
But someone may say they were "custom made" for the tourist market, I call them "hand made" for tourists, not "custom" made for tourists.
Mr. Blavonski, whether you do or don't consider me any kind of "authority of sorts in regards to Cuban Music, culture and it's drums" or any kind of web site has absolutely nothing to do with those of us that think that a pair of bongoes made with Spanish Ceder, black Walnut, African Mahogany and that start at a particular price point is completely acceptable and is not a "a status symbol purchase".
Well, I think it does considering that what you have praised about the work of Jay B and Mat Smith, is their mainting a Traditional Cuban aesthetik in regard to form in the building of thier drums.
Someone need not be an authority re: Cuban Music, culture, by stating those two makers maintain a specific esthetic, which just happens to be Cuban.
Adding some kind of rubber and metal "floating" block between two bongoes is far from any so called Cuban esthetic.
But for some folks to make "written in stone" statements: "stratospheric", "insane price", "overpriced", "a status symbol purchase" etc. shows a lack of something, I don't what to call it other than going into shock from perhaps never having experienced owning a custom made conga or pair of bongoes that cost more that $200.00-$300.00-$400.00?
I don't think these adjectives show a lack of any kind on those including myself who have used them, it simply expresses their opinion, that greatly contrasts with yours.
As I agree that someone is entitled to a personal opinion re: pricing as well as what they choose/like/prefer to play, I don't agree with with someone stating flat out that those prices are "stratospheric", "insane", "overpriced", "a status symbol purchase" which basically tells me they give no validity to purchasing and owning a higher end musical instrument.
You seem to relate to saxophones/horns, a novice or intermediate player or student buys a horn they can comfortably afford, there then comes a time where they become a proficient excellent Jazz/Latin/rock/classical player.... and they then buy a higher end horn which 99.9% of the time is not from a flea market or a pawn shop.
Mr. Blavonski could you kindly share with me what for you personally would consider to be a price for a pair of bongoes that at 1.00 more would be overpriced and at 1.00 over would be "a status symbol purchase"?
To me a musical instrument is "too expensive" if someone simply can't afford the price, or alternatively the quality/fit/finish/materials and sound is absolutely not equitable to what you get for the price asked.
Or, I would add, said quality/fit/finish can be had for less.
"a musical instrument is "too expensive" if someone simply can't afford the price"
I agree with you on that.
"Or alternatively the quality/fit/finish/materials and sound is absolutely not equitable to what you get for the price asked."
I'm wondering since you have both seen and played Matts bongoes if you feel that the "the quality/fit/finish/materials and sound is absolutely not equitable to what you get for the price asked" ?
"Or, I would add, said quality/fit/finish can be had for less"
I'm always learning, can you show me or recommend bongoes that are on par with Matts quality/fit/finish/materials for half the price Matt or Jay charges?.
(current pricing, not from the 1980's-90's)
"A drum is a drum, is a drum" is not true in my experience, a finely made custom drum is like a fine violin, cello, viola or bass with the skin choice being like the strings that make the drum sing.
I couldn't agree with you more here.
Cool.. lets shake hands
Some people prefer an affordable bike, others prefer a higher end bike in both materiel's and workmanship, though both get you to the same destination.
Yes, so why buy the BMW when The VW will get you there and back in one peice for the same length of time?
Ummm... because I can afford it, the sound system is superior, and it came will all the "custom" extras I asked for and paid for..
Well, for luxury and because one can afford it and it puts them in the same line as the other BMW owners. We're conditioned to want more than we need and likewise conditioned to work our asses off, slaving, voluntarily that is, in order to aquire it, and some just got it like that. Enjoy your drums.
Good Vibrations,
Mr. Blavonski
El Magnifico wrote:....and we have posted many ideas and blah,blah,blah but we forgot to mention the most important thing in any drum: the SKYN! Yeah,take your $800.00 set and put it on some shitty skins and you'll see what happen. The Skyn is what gives you the sound and everytime you change it, the charasteristics, sound and "character" of your bongo change with it no matter if it is made out of oak, mahogany or mango tree. Now, with the plastic heads en vogue, this situation is easier but for those of us who's been in this field for many years know that in the past the skyn selection were even more critical than the bongo itself! During the 70's, when Oscar D' Leon was making inroads with his orchestra and we started hearing those skyns from Venezuela, everything changed. By that time the only synthetic skin available was the infamous chest X-Ray film that some people installed in their macho, but this was limited to amateurs. I don't remember any pro playing with it, nor any recording either. It was considered a sacrilege to do so in the professional arena. Who could imagine decades later that the plastics would become a kind of standard among the new bongoceros.
You could say that the wood this or the drum size that and it's also correct, but the skyn is what get in contact with your hands and make your bongo sing. My combination is a conga head on the hembra and a Remo or Evans in the macho, except for my 3A who came with thick skyns on both drums. How many of you remember tuning your bongo just before the show started and seeing your macho split from the ring! The new plastics has made everything easier. The new cats has been so accostumed to these heads that for them it's almost impossible to play with real cueros! Months ago we were working a jig and a bongosero asked me to play one tune. After he finished he told me : Holy shit! Those fucking cueros were killing my hands!.
Everything changes. That's the way it is.
RUMBA !
"By that time the only synthetic skin available was the infamous chest X-Ray film that some people installed in their macho, but this was limited to amateurs. I don't remember any pro playing with it, nor any recording either. It was considered a sacrilege to do so in the professional arena."
"the infamous chest X-Ray film that some people installed in their macho"
"Yeah,take your $800.00 set and put it on some shitty skins and you'll see what happen. The Skyn is what gives you the sound and everytime you change it, the charasteristics, sound and "character" of your bongo change with it no matter if it is made out of oak, mahogany or mango tree."
"By that time the only synthetic skin available was the infamous chest X-Ray film that some people installed in their macho, but this was limited to amateurs. I don't remember any pro playing with it, nor any recording either. It was considered a sacrilege to do so in the professional arena."
"the infamous chest X-Ray film that some people installed in their macho"
"Yeah,take your $800.00 set and put it on some shitty skins and you'll see what happen. The Skyn is what gives you the sound and everytime you change it, the charasteristics, sound and "character" of your bongo change with it no matter if it is made out of oak, mahogany or mango tree."
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 42 guests